[edit | delete | history]

Semantic Digital Rights Management System

SemDRMS is an implementation of a Digital Rights Management (DRM) System based on Semantic Web technologies. It is based on the ontologies presented in the Ontological Infrastructure section. These ontologies provide the formal semantics for the copyright domain and the main rights expression languages, MPEG-21 REL and ODRL.

It is important to note the the use of semantic technologies makes the management system capable of dealing with content from a wider perspective that a mere management of access restrictions. The system is capable of managing content in the context of the copyright model provided by the Copyright Ontology, which contitutes its core component, and consequently should be seen as a Copyright Management System.

 Table of Contents

  1. Ontological Infraestructure
  2. Interoperability with RELs
  3. Implementation
  4. Tutorials
  5. Related Projects
  6. Related Publications

Ontological Infrastructure

These are the ontologies used by the Semantic DRM System. The base ontology is the one providing the semantics for the copyright domain, the Copyright Ontology. It is based on the work carried out in the PhD thesis "A Semantic Web Approach to Digital Rights Management".

This base ontology is complemented with ontologies for the main rights expression languages, MPEG-21 REL and ODRL. They are generated automatically from the XML Schemas that define this languages using the XML Semantics Reuse Methodology and the ReDeFer XSD2OWL tool. These ontologies provide the hook points for integrating MPEG-21 REL and ODRL expressions into the SemDRMS ontological framework. More details in the Interoperability with RELs section.

There is also an ontology for the MPEG-21 RDD, which has been generated using and ad-hoc method that translates the MPEG-21 RDD ontology language to OWL.

Copyright Ontology

This ontology is the basic building block of the SemDRMS ontological infrastructure. It provides the fundamental primitives for the copyright domain, which can be used to model rights statements, agreements, offers, etc. Altogether, it allows modelling the whole copyright value chain. There are more details in the Copyright Ontology web page.

Ontologies for MPEG-21 REL

MPEG-21 REL is composed of the XML schemas for the Core, Standard Extensions and Multimedia Extensions, all of them are mapped to OWL ontologies. Moreover, the previous XML schemas import the schemas for XML Digital Signature and XML Encryption, which are also mapped to OWL ontologies:

  • REL Ontology for the Core:
    • Last version (2006/01): OWL
  • REL Ontology for the Standard Extensions:
    • Last version (2006/01): OWL
  • REL Ontology for the Multimedia Extensions:
    • Last version (2006/01): OWL
  • Ontology for XML Digital Signature (used in the REL Ontologies):
    • Last version (2006/01): OWL
  • Ontology for XML Encryption (used in the REL Ontologies):
    • Last version (2006/01): OWL

Once they are mapped to ontologies, it is possible to make a drawing for the combined REL Ontologies: GIF

Ontologies for MPEG-21 RDD

  • Rights Data Dictionary Ontology:

Ontologies for ODRL 1.1

  • ODRL-EX-11:
    • Last version (2006/01): OWL
  • ODRL-DD-11:
    • Last version (2006/01): OWL

Drawings for the combined ODRL Ontologies:

Interoperability with RELs

As it has been said, the XSD2OWL mappings has been aplied to generate OWL ontologies for the XML Schemas that define the MPEG-21 and ODRL RELs. From this point, it is also possible to map XML instances, i.e. rights expressions like offers or licenses. This is performed by the ReDeFer XML2RDF tool, which transforms the XML tree into a RDF graph and enrichs it semantically. This enrichment is performed by connecting the RDF resources to the concept definitions in the OWL ontologies corresponding to the involved XML Schemas.

The following sections show examples of such mappings for MPEG-21 REL and ODRL.

MPEG-21 REL to RDF

The XML2RDF mapping has been applied to the following examples:

ODRL to RDF

The same XML2RDF mapping can be applied to ODRL instances. For instance, it has been applied to some rights scenarios included in the ODRL 1.1 Specification:

Implementation

The implementation of the DRMS is based on the OWL-DL version of the Copyright Ontology. Therefore, it is based on Description Logic (DL) tools.

Licenses and modelled as OWL Classes and copyrighted content inteded uses are modelled as instances. Then, in order to check if a usage (instance) is authorised by a set of licenses (classes) a DL reasoner is used to classify the instance in the available classes. If the instance is classified into a class that models an agreement, the Agree class as specified in the Copyright Ontology, the usage is authorised.

The implementation is actually work in progress. Pellet is being used in order to implement DL classification as it deals with nominals (e.g. used to define classes of authorised users) and custom datatype (e.g. used to define authorisation time spans).

Overcoming Open World Assumption

The main problem of this OWL-DL implementation is that of the Open World Assumption (OWA) of Description Logics. The OWL-DL primitives that lead to OWA problems are the for all restriction (∀R.C) and the maximum cardinality restriction (≤ n R).

In order to avoid the open world when we want to model a restriction of a license slot to just values from a class, the idea is to negate the restriction and move the negation to the metalevel. The negation is modelled at the metalevel introducing the Disagree class, which is the opposite to the Agree class.

Therefore, the "for all" restriction on the theme of an Agree, i.e. Agree theme ∀R.C, is converted into a "for some" restriction on the theme of a Disagree, i.e. Disagree theme ∃R.¬C. On the other hand, the "maximum cardinality" restriction on the theme of an Agree, i.e. Agree theme (≤ n R), is converted into a "minimum cardinality" restriction on the theme of a Disagree, i.e. Disagree theme (≥ n+1 R).

Tutorials

Smart University'07"DRM, from research to implementation" track, Smart University 2007
September 19-20, Sophia Antipolis, France
Title: "Enabling interoperable and rights-aware DRM using the SemanticWeb" PPT slideshow

 

Related Projects

MediaMixer Logo

 

2012-2014 MediaMixer (EU FP7-318101)
Community and Networking for the Remixing of Online Media
Support Action
http://mediamixer.eu

 

2009-2011 OMediaDis Spanish Government (TIN2008-06228)
Open Plataform for Multichannel Content Distribution Management, http://omediadis.udl.cat

Related Publications

NOTE: This site links to the draft versions of the papers. For final versions, please, contact the corresponding publisher.


A Semantic Web Approach to 
Digital Rights Management 

García, R.
VDM Verlag Dr. Müller, 2010
ISBN 978-3-639-15740-6
A Semantic Web Approach to Digital Rights Management Cover

Controlled Natural Language rendering of Copyright Ontology licenses PDF slideshow

García, R.; Gil, R.
8th International Workshop for Technical, Economic and Legal Aspects of Business Models for Virtual Goods, Virtual Goods'10
30 September - 1 October 2010, Namur, Belgium
Namur University Press, pp. 61-76, 2010
ISBN 978-2-87037-682-9 

Content Value Chains Modelling using a Copyright Ontology PDF

García, R.; Gil, R.Information Systems, Vol. 35, No. 4, pp. 483-495. Elsevier, 2010
ISSN 0306-4379 / DOI: 10.1016/j.is.2008.12.001

 

Open Platform for Multichannel Media Distribution Management HTML

García, R.;Gimeno, J.M.
Position paper, W3C Workshop on the Future of Social Networking, 15-16 January 2009, Barcelona

Copyright Licenses Reasoning using an OWL-DL Ontology PDF

García, R.; Gil, R.
In Breuker, J.; Casanovas, P.; Klein, M.; Francesconi, E. (Eds.) Law, Ontologies and the Semantic Web
Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence and Applications, Vol. 188, pp. 145-162. IOS Press, 2009
ISBN 978-1-58603-942-4

Copyright Management for the LUISA Semantic Learning Content Management System PDF PPT slideshow

García, R.; Pariente, T.
1st World Summit on the Knowledge Society, WSKS'08
Lecture Notes in Artificial Intelligence, Vol. 5288, pp. 253-262. Springer, 2008
ISBN 978-3-540-87780-6

A Web Ontology for Copyright Contracts Management PDF

García, R.; Gil, R.
Special issue on "Contract Architectures and Languages".
International Journal of Electronic Commerce
, in press. M.E. Sharpe, 2007
ISSN 1086-4415

Promoting Music Sampling by Semantic Web-enhanced DRM tools PDF

Springer, M.; García. R.
5th International Workshop for Technical, Economic and Legal Aspects of Business Models for Virtual Goods, Virtual Goods'07
Nova Science Publishers, 2007. In press

A Web Ontologies Framework for Digital Rights Management PDF

García, R.; Gil, R. and Delgado, J.
Journal of Artificial Intelligence and Law, Vol. 15, No. 2, pp. 137-154. Springer-Verlag, 2007
ISSN 0924-8463

Semantic Digital Rights Management for Controlled P2P RDF Metadata Diffusion PDF

García, R.; Tummarello, G.
2nd International Semantic Web Policy Workshop, SWPW'06
International Semantic Web Conference, Athens, USA, 2006
CEUR Workshop Proceedings, Vol. 207, pp. 102-109, 2006
ISSN 1613-0073

An OWL Copyright Ontology for Semantic Digital Rights Management PDF

García, R.; Gil, R.
IFIP WG 2.12 & WG 12.4 International Workshop on Web Semantics, SWWS'06
Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Vol. 4278, pp. 1745-1754. Springer-Verlag, 2006
ISBN 3-540-48273-3

An Ontological Approach for the Management of Rights Data Dictionaries PDF PPT

García, R. and Delgado, J.
18th Annual Conference on Legal Knowledge and Information Systems, JURIX 2005
Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence and Applications, Vol. 134, IOS Press, 2005
ISBN 1-58603-576-2

Architecture of a Semantic XPath Processor PDF

Tous, R.; García, R.; Rodríguez, E. and Delgado, J.
E-Commerce and Web Technologies: 6th International Conference, EC-Web 2005
Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Vol. 3590, pp 1 - 10. Springer-Verlag, 2005
ISBN 3-540-28467-2

Formalising ODRL Semantics using Web Ontologies PDF

García, R.; Gil, R.; Gallego, I. and Delgado, J.
Open Digital Rights Language Workshop, ODRL 2005

An interoperable framework for IPR using web ontologies PDF

Gil, R.; García, R. and Delgado, J.
Legal Ontologies and Artificial Intelligence Techniques, LOAIT 2005
IAAIL Workshop Series, pp. 135-148. Wolf Legal Publishers, 2005
ISBN 90-5850-504-9

Intellectual Property Rights Management using a Semantic Web Information System PDF

García, R., Gil, R. and Delgado, J.
OTM Confederated International Conferences, CoopIS, DOA, and ODBASE 2004
Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Vol. 3291, pp 689 - 704. Springer-Verlag, 2004
ISBN 3-540-23662-7